Glendale legal battle with Coyotes leaves Westgate businesses in limbo
By Tyler Freader, Cronkite News | Friday, June 19, 2015
GLENDALE – For Westgate Entertainment District business owners, the opportunity of making a living right outside Gila River Arena was too good to pass up.
Now, however, that opportunity may have been too good to be true.
After the Glendale City Council voted June 10 to terminate the city’s lease and arena management deal with the Arizona Coyotes, Westgate’s tenants are left concerned about what the effect could be on their bottom line if the NHL franchise leaves Glendale.
Alan Krier, managing partner at OPA Life Greek Café, said the vote to terminate the lease came as a surprise to him.
“My first reaction was I didn’t believe it,” Krier said. “It was one of bewilderment.”
Krier said OPA sees about a 40 percent drop off in revenue between weekend game nights and game nights during the week.
“On a weekend game night it could get up to a $9,000 or $10,000 day and up,” Krier said. “On a nongame Saturday, it could get up to $6,000.”
On June 12, a Maricopa Superior Court judge granted the Coyotes a temporary restraining order, allowing the team to stay in Gila River Arena for the time being.
As the legal process continues, Krier says contingency plans haven’t been made for the potential departure of the Coyotes.
“It’s too soon to speculate,” Krier said. “We wouldn’t close per se, but we’d have to think of alternative plans and alternative plans on how to market our unit here.
“No matter what we do, it’s going to hurt.”
Next-door to OPA is Fresh Healthy Café, which also opened in 2014. Owner J.J. Girn said the Coyotes games aren’t just useful on weekends, but also help bring in customers on weekdays.
“I think the big positive with the hockey being here is that a lot of their games are during the week,” Girn said. “That helps bring clientele in on a Tuesday, or a Wednesday or a Thursday when, generally, malls and restaurants aren’t as busy.
“Anytime you’re driving extra clients, extra customers, extra people to come do something, it’s going to generate revenue not just for me but for everybody.”
Girn said many of the issues that could arise if the Coyotes leave stand unresolved, including what would happen to customers who primarily come to Westgate because of the hockey team.
“Are we going to do different events to try to bring clientele in?” asked Girn. “And what about the people that are going to be upset that the Coyotes are leaving? Are they going to come back to Westgate? A lot of those questions are unanswered at this point.”
Westgate has had financial troubles seemingly since its inception in the early 2000s, when developer Steve Ellman, former owner of the Coyotes, envisioned a giant sports and entertainment district in Glendale.
The first phase of the complex opened in 2006. Westgate has struggled to maintain tenants and in 2011, Ellman lost the property to foreclosure. iStar Financial, a finance and investment company based in New York City, now owns the property, while Vestar Development Co., whose corporate headquarters are in Phoenix, is Westgate’s property management firm.
Mark Stapp, executive director of the master’s of real estate development program at Arizona State University’s W.P. Carey School of Business, said development projects like Westgate come with an understood amount of risk and that the economic downturn was a major factor that contributed to Westgate’s early problems.
“Here’s what happens with these projects: They are ambitious,” Stapp said. “They have many components to them that require close coordination for success to occur.
“Certainly no one had control over the recession. I think it’s hard to look at this project without considering that context.”
Stapp, who worked for Ellman’s real estate and investment group, The Ellman Cos. from 1988 to 1993, says that Ellman’s ability to put Westgate together was worthy of praise.
“You’ve got to consider the fact that University of Phoenix Stadium is certainly a help to any business that’s in Westgate in addition to (Gila River Arena) itself. Those are huge accomplishments,” Stapp said.
Houssein Jabbar, owner of Snackland, a convenience store that opened at Westgate in 2011, called the move by the Glendale City Council unbecoming.
“For the city of Glendale to take action and terminate the lease like that was shocking,” Jabbar said.
“If you make a deal, if you sign a contract, you should hold up your end of the deal and you should hold up your end of the contract,” Jabbar said. “I think the way the city of Glendale went about it was somewhat unprofessional.
“To go about and cancel it like that when it’s only been two or three years into the contract, it doesn’t really look too good.”
The next step in the legal battle between the Coyotes and Glendale is a pretrial conference scheduled June 29.