Lawmakers balk at White House reuniting Central American families
By Miranda Leo, Cronkite News | Friday, April 24, 2015
WASHINGTON – An Obama administration program that reunites Central American children with parents who have immigrated to the U.S. faced sharp questioning Thursday from senators, who worried that it would further dilute immigration standards.
The program was started in response to the flood of unaccompanied minors who showed up at the Southwest border last summer, after dangerous journeys from their Central American homes to rejoin family members who had come to the U.S.
A State Department official told the Senate Judiciary Committee that the Central American Minors Refugee/Parole Program would help prevent another surge of children trying to make that same dangerous trek.
“The administration established this program to provide a safe, legal, orderly alternative to the dangerous journey that some children are currently undertaking to join their parents in the United States,” said Simon Henshaw, principal deputy assistant secretary at State’s Bureau of Population, Refugees, and Migration, in his written testimony.
The program, announced in November, has started accepting applications but had not yet acted on any of the 500 or so applications.
Committee members expressed concern Thursday about the concept as well as the execution of the program.
Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, and others asked whether administration definitions of who is a refugee or parolee – key factors in being accepted to the program – were being applied too liberally.
“If you look at the statute, the statute is pretty particular and specific in terms of the requirement: A past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion,” Cornyn said. “It seems to me like basically in the refugee qualifications, or requirement of refugees to prove what the statute requires, we’ve gotten rather far afield.”
The Senate hearing came as Rep. Paul Gosar, R-Prescott, was preparing to deliver a letter co-signed by 36 House members demanding an immediate halt to the program.
Gosar said Thursday that the Central American program follows the White House’s “illegal” efforts to extend deportation protection to millions of immigrants under DACA and DAPA – the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals and Deferred Action for Parents of Americans programs.
“What this is doing is it’s extending this in a unilateral aspect by the president,” Gosar said of the family reunification program. “This is in complete violation of what the Constitution says.”
Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., told the committee a story of an immigrant in his state who was granted deferred deportation status and later killed three people. Tillis voiced his concern about how well background checks would be carried out, to prevent similar occurrences.
“I’d like to get some assurance from you all that you can confidently and unequivocally say that your agency is not going to make the same errors,” Tillis said to Henshaw and Joseph Langlois, a witness from Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Other witnesses noted that the Central American program is not the first of its kind. The U.S. has run similar resettlement programs with families divided between this country and Vietnam, Cuba and Haiti, they said.
But critics said that this program, unlike the others, includes families given legal status by President Barack Obama’s DACA and DAPA programs.
“A person provided legal status in this country who came here illegally, in violation of our law, that received legal presence by order of the president is now able to bring in, under the president’s order, his (or) her spouse and children,” said Sen. Jeff Sessions, R-N.C.
“When government policies take actions … that suggest, ‘If you’d like to get to America, bring your family, one member can go forward and will later be able to bring them in and get legal status,'” Sessions said, “then you’ve created a dangerous situation.”
The Central American Minors Refugee/Parole Program aims to reunite Central American immigrants who are legally in the United States with family members they left behind. To qualify:
• Minors in El Salvador, Guatemala or Honduras must have a parent legally present and documented in the U.S. (includes those deferred deportation under the president’s executive action);
• The parent must contact a local resettlement agency, which helps them submit an application for an interview;
• DNA testing must confirm a biological parent-child relationship, and the minor must pass a background check;
• The child must be interviewed in the home country to determine if he or she meets the standard to be considered a refugee;
• If not a refugee, minors must show that they are at risk for harm if they stay in their home country, granting them eligibility for parole on a case-by-case basis (which would need to be renewed after two years);
• Other family members can be resettled if he or she is part of the same household and economic unit as the qualifying child, is legally married to the qualifying parent at the time of application, or continues to be legally married to the qualifying parent.